Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Elisabeth Robson's avatar

Just this morning I filled out a form that asked me my gender and gave me many options, including other. I chose "other" and wrote in "I don't have a gender; my sex is female." I do that whenever I have that option.

Expand full comment
nosey parker's avatar

I was at a demo yesterday, had a great time seeing old friends and had ongoing conversation with woman [SIC] standing next to me. Then she starts talking about transgender rights. I said transwomen are men. She got very hostile. I couldn't really understand why she was mad but then the younger woman next to her said intersex are 2% of the population. (Which I found out is not true--it's more like 0.018% or one out of every 5500 births but I guess the schools don't teach math anymore either.) I said I think transwomen are gay men with fetishes about women's clothing. Then she said, apropos of nothing (I thought), "Do you want to see my penis?" So, always up for a new experience, I said, "Sure!" She jumped about six feet and got the younger one between us and started shouting about me being a bigot and that I wanted to see her dick. It really soured the whole demo for me. What I wanted was for her to watch Jennifer Bilek's discussion about the money behind the trans movement since we were out in the street complaining about the billionaire bros. Seemed relevant to me. But her mind was shut tight. I am so over this. I tried to explain to her that women were rendered non-existent if transwomen are considered women but she went into full-blown drama queen territory. I despair of normal people being able to fight back against what is happening in our governments and societies right now. I hesitate to call it authoritarianism because I think it's something worse and much bigger. There are so many issues that divide us. It feels hopeless.

Are intersex considered trans? They all are unique and completely different from each other. What the hey? And they actually have gonadal and hormonal and chromosomal issues which transwomen do not. I believe they all have both X and Y chromosomes. It's probably politically incorrect but in private I just refer to them as hermaphrodites.

I resent taxpayers paying for all these hormonal treatments and surgeries, but I'm entirely open to free APPROPRIATE healthcare for intersex people. But true intersex are incredibly rare. At 0.018% that's slightly over 6,000 people in the entire United States and far less in the U.K.

As for gender, fuck it. It's always been used against me. I just see it as academic jargon and I reject all academic and professional jargon. That's a tool to establish who is inside and who is outside. We don't need more dividers that determine who has a right to an opinion and who does not. (Although if you don't have a vagina and uterus your opinion about abortion is likely beside the point,) I always seem to be outside. As for socialization for my sex, that's the reason my house is a mess. I spent my childhood doing housework (against my will) and sewing women's clothing for myself (against my will) and buying bras (against my will) instead of creating things I wanted to create with peers that I do as little housework as is possible, which is very little since my only roommates have four legs and like things to stink.

Not sure this is a real response to your question but I just had to get it off my (hairless) chest.

Expand full comment
32 more comments...

No posts